Compare Renters Insurance Quotes

Compare Renters Insurance Quotes [Cheapest Online Quotes 2022]

Bucky Wucky does have sponsors, and we may work with companies to provide you with the best content, information, and data on business and personal finance. Some links on our site may be affiliate links. While our sponsors may pay us, we only work with companies that align with Bucky Wucky’s values.

Compare Renters Insurance Quotes

If you don’t own a home, you should still have insurance coverage to protect all of your valuables. Good renters insurance can give you peace of mind that the items you care about – from family heirlooms to your new computer or television – are covered in case of theft, fire, or some other unforeseen and catastrophic event. 

However, there are hundreds of renters insurance policies out there, and it can be difficult to find the right one for your personal needs. It is also often tough to determine whether or not you got the best price on the policy you choose, too.

Fortunately, thanks to the internet, there are more insurance comparison tools out there than ever before. Here is some advice on purchasing renters insurance, along with a few great websites you can check out right now to compare renters insurance quotes.

Helpful Links

Curadebt: Curadebt offers FREE debt relief counseling as one of the most trusted providers.

Mainvest: Invest in businesses with Mainvest and take a share of the profits.

Goalry: Goalry is a FREE personal finance app that helps you achieve your financial goals.

Koinly: Koinly helps you calculate and reduce your cryptocurrency taxes.

Cryptohopper: Cryptohopper offers a powerful, world-class AI-powered crypto trading bot.

Get at Least Three Quotes

While it can be confusing searching for a good renters insurance policy, you can do a little legwork to ensure that you choose the coverage you need at a decent price. For starters, you should never settle with just one quote, no matter how good you think it is.

The Insurance Information Institute recommends that you get at least three quotes so that you can compare them. This will help you make a more informed decision when you ultimately choose your policy. 

When you do compare the different insurance policies, you shouldn’t just be looking at the pricing alone, either. Instead, you should also look at other key aspects of the policy, such as the amount of coverage you’re receiving for your valuables or the deductible.

Sometimes the lowest priced renters insurance policy is not a good deal at all. You should also consider taking advantage of some of the comparison websites out there to help you shop around, too. Here are a few worth checking out.

Compare Quotes For Renters Insurance


Gabi is an insurance comparison website with a twist: if you already have renters insurance, it can help you find comparable policies at a better price.

You simply enter your insurance information into Gabi on an online form, and within a minute or two it will provide you several comparable quotes to consider alongside the policy you already have. So, if you think you could’ve gotten a better policy when you originally purchased your renter’s insurance, Gabi is a great way to make sure.

The site, which is free to use,  and also allows you to compare and shop for renters insurance even if you don’t already have a policy too.


If you’re just starting out on your hunt for good, affordable renters insurance, a great place to begin is at RenterQuotes. This site is a simple yet effective way to commence comparison shopping.

You simply fill out an online form with some basic info, and the site will send you a few initial quotes on rental insurance policies. You’ll be able to travel to the companies’ websites to learn more if you’re interested in the quotes they provide, too.

While the quotes provided are only estimates – the actual insurance premiums may change after you provide the companies additional information, RenterQuotes can help you get an understanding of what renters insurance will cost as you continue to shop for affordable coverage.

The Zebra

The Zebra is a great insurance comparison site you can use to check out renter insurance. All you have to do is enter a bit of information about yourself and what you’re looking for on the site; Zebra does the rest for you. 

As soon as you input all of the info Zebra needs, it will compile a list of renters insurance policies for you to look at. You’ll be able to rapidly see the coverage you’d get as well as a rate quote, and you can advance to the insurer’s website with a single click to follow up.

Since The Zebra also allows you to compare and shop for other types of insurance, including car and homeowner’s policies, you’ll definitely want to bookmark this site for future reference.


PolicyGenius is another full-service insurance comparison website that you should check out. Like the Zebra, this site asks you for some very basic information about the type of renters insurance you are looking for; it then pulls up a series of quotes that allows you to comparison shop and choose a policy you believe is the best fit for you.

You can also go from the PolicyGenius site to the insurer’s site when you find a policy you want to look at more closely.

Besides comparing insurance and shopping for an affordable policy, this site has a wealth of information about insurance that can help make you a more informed consumer as well.


If you want to try something a bit different in your search for affordable renters insurance, you should definitely check out Lemonade. The Lemonade platform is a unique, peer-to-peer site that channels people in similar risk groups into policies.

Lemonade normally charges a nominal fee upfront to cover their costs and make a profit. This is a considerably different model than conventional insurance models, and many people who choose to seek renters insurance from the site could realize savings that would not be available from conventional insurance companies.

Since it offers several different classes of policies beyond renters insurance, it is another good website to bookmark in case you need it in the future.

Compare, Compare, Compare! 

When it comes to purchasing renters insurance, don’t sell yourself short by choosing the first policy you find. Instead, take the time to shop around and compare the policies that are available. If you do, you will likely save money, and you’ll be able to ensure you have the coverage you need to protect everything you value in your apartment or rental home, too. 


Thanks for reading how to compare renters insurance quotes

You may also be interested in our Policygenius review.